Magnemo vs Claude memory and Projects
| Magnemo 0.6.7 | Claude memory and Projects, from their docs | |
|---|---|---|
| Where memory lives | Your memory lives on your computer, in plain files you can open. IN THE TREE: test_the_network_line_passes_on_the_package_and_fails_on_a_planted_import · test_free_tier_stdlib_only | Memory saved "as a set of individual topics"; listed under Settings > Memory > Topics; "stored with encryption at rest." Each project has "its own separate memory space". [S1] |
| Who writes an entry | The only write verb. Lands in IN THE TREE: test_lists_exactly_four_tools · test_promotion_is_not_a_tool · test_the_author_is_the_seat_and_a_keyholder_claim_is_refused | Claude, automatically "as you chat"; user can "tell Claude to 'remember this' to save something directly." [S1] |
| What is kept without your yes | Agent writes NEVER reach canonical stores directly — staging only, always. IN THE TREE: test_staging_is_the_only_note_write_path · test_retrieve_excludes_staged | not stated in their docs (read 2026-10-02). Only after-save notice for sensitive topics: "a notice appears above the message box so you can review it". [S1] |
| What an entry carries (who, when, approved) | Every note is markdown with provenance frontmatter (author, written, source, status, reviewed_by, supersedes, strength). IN THE TREE: test_stage_lands_in_staging_with_provenance_and_salience · test_paperless_and_malformed_notes_refused · governance.promote | not stated in their docs (read 2026-10-02). No author, timestamp, origin or lineage fields documented. |
| Portable across clients | Anything that speaks MCP over stdio mounts the same way. IN THE TREE: test_connect_and_list_over_stdio | Text. Prompt Claude to "Write out your memories of me verbatim"; import by pasting text ("Add to memory"). "All memory data is included in data exports." [S1][S2] Export file format not stated [S3]. |
| License | Python 3.11+, zero dependencies, Apache-2.0. IN THE TREE: LICENSE | not stated in their docs (read 2026-10-02) |
Claude Projects [S4]: project knowledge base and instructions documented; no memory-entry fields or export of project knowledge stated.
THEIR PAGES, READ 2026-10-02. EVERY PHRASE IN QUOTATION MARKS WAS FOUND ON ONE OF THEM, CHECKED 2026-10-02.
- https://support.claude.com/en/articles/11817273-use-claude-s-chat-search-and-memory-to-build-on-previous-context
- https://support.claude.com/en/articles/12123587-import-and-export-your-memory-from-claude
- https://support.claude.com/en/articles/9450526-how-can-i-export-my-claude-data
- https://support.claude.com/en/articles/9517075-what-are-projects
Corrections welcome: open an issue.